OK, so here’s my take on it at the moment. ..
I don’t think he’s a racist, but I think his comment was over the line. Most of the time he takes on politicians, journalists who are in the public arena already. These were college girls, so it’s not like they were going to come on the show and call him on stuff and banter with him about it.
I think he should have been fired not because what he said was ignorant, per se, but because of the above. NBC and CBS are businesses and just like any business they can fire for whatever they want. If he was being censored in some way by the government, then that’s another question.
I actually like Imus. He can actually be quite enlightened and is quite smart (despite making this comment, which shows mostly that he’s a flawed person, like most of us). When we say or do stupid things, there are consequences even if we didn’t really mean it or whatever.
I feel the same way about him that I do Nifong of the Duke Lacrosse case — he shot his mouth off before really checking everything out and now, he’s probably ruined his career. That doesn’t mean he’s not a good lawyer or hasn’t been an effective DA/ public servant — it means only that he’s hot-headed and probably ambitious. It’s unfortunate that he’s probably gone but that’s just the way it is.
So back to Imus, in a way, I’m glad that CBS and NBC acted so quickly because it’s maybe showing that the press/media is growing some balls again, so to speak. They didn’t challenge the administration enough about Iraq, etc. I don’t think taking more time to have more “healing” discussions would have done any good except to inflame racial tensions for those who think that while corporations may want to appear to be beyond racism and bigotry by having high profile meetings with self-proclaimed leaders of the African-American community, they, by their actions (in keeping Imus on, for example) are continuing to condone such attitudes.
I just don’t see if as a free speech issue. . .